True, the comic isn't like that All The Time. But it isn't consistent All The Time anyway save for its style and characterization. But more to the point, if you need to put up a sample story arc that can stand more or less on its own yet remain readable, OU is much better than Torg Potter. I think the sense of humor and drama are both encapsulated pretty well by OU; but all Torg Potter has is parody, which is only a fraction of what makes Sluggy *Sluggy Freelance*. Most of the people I know who dislike OU dislike how long it is and that Bunbun is the sole link back to the normal world, but
everyone I know who dislikes Torg Potter finds it outright unfunny save for a few moments. And yes, that's my opinion of it as well.
Its kind of hard to find good self-contained story arcs in Sluggy that retain the element of drama, especially after the first couple years. Stories which I can point new readers to and say "basically this is a spinoff, see if you like it". Oceans Unmoving is like that. Torg Potter and Years of YarnCraft are both like that, but I question the quality of both and would recommend new readers to
avoid those story arcs unless they are specifically interested in seeing a parody of Harry Potter and World of Warcraft respectively. If you can think of any other stories like them that don't rely on overly narrow parody, I would be welcome to hear about them (it has been a while since I've touched some parts of the archive myself).