Seriously, it was really hard to rank them, but here they are in order of increasing love.Edguy: I loved the Arson, Murder and Jaywalking ending to this piece. While I do enjoy a piece that leaves some things to the imagination, I felt this one relied on the reader's imagination a little too much; I was left with what I felt was too vague an idea of what happened.
Steave: I thought it was clever hooking into the 2012 hype, and I liked how the diary's author looks back at his previous entry with a different attitude. One thing that did kind of bring it down for me is the fact that the pre-disaster entry is on December 30, when the so-called Mayan apocalypse is supposed to occur on December 21.
Dom/SlimKop: I had to laugh at this one, and not just because a cat died. (Kidding, kidding.) It seemed a little too brief for me to get much more out of it, but it was a good laugh in the midst of something rather ominous, which feels like the point.
kitoba: This piece reminded me of The Ring. I like the idea of the diary itself being an Artifact of Death. It did seem a little farfetched to me that the next owner would not only find it and start writing in it the very next day, but that they'd use the exact same words.
chaosman: I know people who would probably write messages just like this. It felt very real. I sincerely hope that the news of a soldier's death is not today or ever delivered by email, but the fact that it is delivered that way here makes me wonder at the circumstances. Is the recipient in a really isolated location? Or have things just grown more impersonal in the future? Oddly, I found myself thinking most about the thoughts and feelings of Captain Patel. How must she feel writing this message? Is she agonizing over how woefully inadequate the message feels to her? Or is this just one of hundreds that she's had to compose, and writing them has become rote?
CCC: In terms of emotional content, this piece truly felt like what someone would write if they knew for sure that they would be the last words they'd ever give to the one they love. The vagueness of the event does lead me to wonder about some of the details. If the person were interrupted mid-composition by whatever caused the wreckage, how did the message itself survive? (One thought that occurred to me is that this might be Wolverine scratching a message into a metal plate using his adamantium claws!) The other thing that struck me was that if I was writing my last words to my wife, the next thing I'd want to say after "I love you" would be a brief description of what's about to kill me, but maybe I'm just more practical than the message's author. But these were mere quibbles in the face of the wonderful emotion evident in the piece.
inspiration: Wow. Mr. Incredible's gone dark. We think of superheroes as men and women of steel, so I always like it when someone who is physically nearly invulnerable is shown to be much less so emotionally. Not only that, but the hero's very much less than perfect. He or she comes across as depressed, bitter, self-recriminating; they feel complex and nuanced even in this short passage. The Wham Line near the end was perfect and left me wanting to know more. Who is the buddy? A sidekick? A fellow superhero? Or just a close non-super friend?
Anyway, so inspiration wins! However, since she already won the first round, we'll have the author of the second place story start the next round. Go, CCC!





